The Supreme Court has clarified the proper legal remedies for recovering land, affirming that property owner Lea Victa-Espinosa correctly filed a case to regain possession of her lot in Cavite.
In a ruling penned by Associate Justice Ricardo Rosario, the Court En Banc said Espinosa properly filed an accion publiciana against spouses Noel and Leny Agullo, who refused to vacate a portion of the land she had purchased.
The case stemmed from Espinosa’s discovery that the Agullos were occupying part of her property. After her demand for them to leave was ignored, she sought relief before the Regional Trial Court (RTC).
The RTC dismissed her complaint, ruling that it was premature since it was filed less than a year after the alleged dispossession, when she should have instead filed an ejection case.
Later, the Court of Appeals reversed the ruling, treating Espinosa’s case as an accion reivindicatoria, a legal remedy based on ownership.
In response, the Agullos elevated the matter to the high court, insisting that the case was a premature accion publiciana.
However, the Supreme Court denied their petition. It explained that while ejectment suits are available within one year if force, intimidation, threat, strategy, or stealth is involved, an accion publiciana may be filed even earlier if such circumstances are absent. Since Espinosa did not allege that Agullos used any of these means, the Court said her case was correctly filed.
The high tribunal also reiterated the distinctions: ejection covers unlawful possession within a year; accion publiciana involves possession disputes beyond a year or without forceful entry; and accion reivindicatoria seeks both ownership and possession., This news data comes from:http://xs888999.com
SC clarifies rules on land ownership
The Supreme Court ordered the RTC to proceed with trial and resolve the case.
- US Spirit Airlines files for bankruptcy again
- Anti-fake news bill filed anew in House
- Japanese climber, 102, sets Mount Fuji record
- Marcos, first lady visit Cambodia to boost ties
- Rains over Metro Manila, parts of PH as LPA may develop into 'short-lived' tropical depression
- India to cut taxes on hundreds of consumer goods to boost local demand following steep US tariffs
- Remulla pledges transparency and impartiality as Ombudsman
- Sen. Go files bills to push health, social, and labor reforms
- US appeals court blocks Trump's use of wartime law for deportations
- 25 countries suspend postal services to US over tariffs – UN
